CookieCutter.com Horizontal Logo
0

Recipes The Whole Family Can Enjoy

Royal Icing

Ingredients:

4 cups powdered sugar

3 Tbsp meringue powder

½ tsp cream of tartar

½ cup water (add 2-4 Tbsp as needed)

1tsp vanilla

Food coloring


In a large bowl mix powdered sugar, meringue, and cream of tartar. Once combined, add water and vanilla. Beat at low speed until combined and then finish at high speed for 7-10 minutes or until stiff. Add water to thin icing. Divide icing, add coloring of choice, and enjoy decorating gorgeous cookies!


The Best Sugar Cookie Recipe

Ingredients:

1 cup softened butter

3/4 cup sugar

1 egg

1 1/2 tsp. vanilla

3 cups flour

1/2 tsp. salt


Preheat oven to 350 ° F and line baking sheet with parchment paper or a silicone liner. Mix butter then beat in sugar, followed by eggs and vanilla. In a separate bowl, mix flower and salt. Gradually combine dry ingredients with wet. Chill dough 2-4 hours or overnight  before rolling at 1/4 inches thick. Cut using the shape of your choice and bake 9-10 min. To avoid rust wipe down cutters and hand dry immediately.  Enjoy!

Cinnamon Ornaments Recipe

Supplies:

One 4.12 oz. bottle of cinnamon

3/4 cup applesauce

2-3 Tbsp white glue

1 tsp cloves

Straw

Ribbon


Combine cinnamon, applesauce, and glue until it feels like a playdough consistency (you may need to use your hands to mix fully). Next, roll out the dough until it reaches 1/4-inch to 1/3-inch thickness. Cut dough into desired shapes and use the straw to make a hole at the top of each ornament. Bake at 200 ° for 2 1/2 hours OR let them air dry for 1-2 days--turning over periodically. Decorate and hang them on the tree for a perfect homemade touch. To avoid rust wipe down cookie cutters and towel dry immediately after use. Enjoy!

Chocolate Sugar Cookie Recipe by Sweetopia!

Ingredients:

2 cups unsalted butter

2 cups sugar

2 large eggs

3 tsp vanilla

4 cups all-purpose flower

1 ½ cups cocoa powder

1 tsp salt


Cream the butter and sugar together in the bowl of an electric mixer on low to medium speed for about 1 minute. Over mixing the butter and sugar will cause cookies to spread, so be brief. Add eggs and vanilla one at a time. Mix dry ingredients together in a separate bowl and then add to the wet ingredients in the mixer. Mix at low speed for about 30 seconds. When the dough clumps around the mixing paddle it is ready. Roll out the dough between 2 pieces of parchment paper and chill for 1-4 hours. Cut into desired shapes and bake at 350 for 8-12 minutes. Using a silicone liner or parchment paper on your baking sheet will help the cookies hold their shape. Decorate and enjoy!

Knox Blox- “Jello Jigglers”

Ingredients:

4 packets Knox unflavored gelatin 

3 packets flavored Jello 


In a bowl mix all the Jello together. Add 4 cups of boiling water and stir until gelatin is completely dissolved. For thicker shapes pour into a 9X13 pan, and for thinner shapes use a sheet pan. Chill until firm and then cut into desired shapes.

Lemon-Cream Cheese Cutouts

Ingredients:

2 ½ cups all-purpose flour

1 cup sugar

½ cup (1 stick) unsalted butter, room temperature

¼ cup cream cheese, room temperature

¼  cup lemon juice

1 large egg, room temperature

1 ½  tablespoons lemon zest

2 teaspoons cornstarch

1 teaspoon vanilla extract

1 teaspoon baking soda

¼ teaspoon salt


Icing:

3/4 cup powdered sugar

1/2 tablespoon milk

1/2 tablespoon lemon juice


Cream together butter and cream cheese until smooth, then mix in sugar, egg, and vanilla extract for 5-6 minutes until fluffy. In a medium bowl, combine flour, lemon zest, cornstarch, baking soda and salt. Alternate between adding the dry ingredients and the lemon juice to the cream cheese mixture. Mix until a rough dough comes together. If needed, add a little more flour so dough isn’t sticky. Roll dough between 2 sheets of parchment paper and chill for 1-4 hours. When ready to bake, preheat oven to 350º F and cut dough into desired shapes. Bake on a silicone or parchment paper lined baking sheet for 10-12 minutes, or until edges are just starting to brown. While cookies are baking, whisk together all icing ingredients until smooth. Add more or less powdered sugar to desired thickness. Let cookies cool completely before drizzling icing, and enjoy!

Popular Questions

Got a question? We’re here to help.


  • How do I clean my cutters?

    Care Instructions


    First thing to note with tin cookie cutters is that Moisture is the ENEMY of your cookie cutters. Always has been and always will be.


    Tin cookie cutters should be gently washed by hand (avoiding the use of

    anything abrasive), and dried promptly to prevent rust. Do not leave them in a sink full of water, or to air dry! They will rust. We suggest the following for the initial cleaning: set your oven on the warm setting, and wash your cookie cutters one at a time. After each one is washed and roughly dried, put them on a clean baking sheet. When all of the cookie cutters are clean, turn your oven off, and put the whole baking sheet in your warm oven. The oven will help dry in the places you can not reach. Basically you're just wanting to get them dried quickly, and thoroughly. Obviously, this method does not apply to the plastic 3D cuttes. More on those below.


    Avoid having the cookie cutters come into contact with anything acidic, as the tinplate can wear off. As mentioned before, tin cookie cutters can be easily bent, so store them carefully. You can hang them on peg board, or store them loosely in bins or drawers. If you put them in any container like this, be careful when sorting through them or putting them away not to force them, as this can result in bending. Also, as the cookie cutters hit against each other they can ding the tinplate and thus cause rusting.


    Plastic Cookie Cutters


    We print our cutters on a 3D printer, using a high quality food safe PLA. The cutters we make are to be washed by hand only in warm soapy water and are not dishwasher safe. Putting the cutters in a dishwasher could melt, warp or otherwise damage the PLA. Hot water is the enemy of plastic cookie cutters. 


    HAND WASH ONLY! NOT dishwasher safe, avoid expoure to hot water/heat, as this can cause the cutters to warp. Hand wash towel dry only.

  • Can I return my order?

    In most cases, yes. 


    If you are dissatisfied with your order for any reason, you can return your items for a prompt refund. Refunds for items returned within 7 days from the time you received your order will be credited in the same form as the original payment type. The original shipping and handling charges are not refundable.


    Returns are accepted in accordance with our Return Policy.

  • How do I track my order?

    Please be aware, due to COVID-19, USPS and FedEx have suspended guaranteed delivery dates until further notice. Arrival dates may change. We will continue to ship packages promptly and are committed to providing the most accurate delivery dates possible.


    We know you like to receive your order quickly and that is our top priority.


    • Most orders ship within 1-2 days!
    • Our shipping rates start at $5.75 (First Class Mail 3-5 days delivery)
    • A tracking number that will be emailed to you when your order ships.
    • Free Shipping on $40 or more of product (void on wholesale orders, international orders and call in orders). 

    Check out our Shipping Policy for more details! 

  • Do you offer pick-up?

    We sure do! Just select the "Pick-up" option when you check out and we will see you soon!

  • Do you make custom cookie cutters?

    We manufacture two kinds of cookie cutters right here in our Pleasant Valley, Missouri facility. Each kind is designed to fit two different needs. We would love to make one for you. Here are the quick facts to help you decide which method is best for you.


    Plastic 3D Printed Cookie Cutter

    1. $25 - $75 one-time design fee per shape
    2. Minimum quantity 25 pieces per design
    3. Made of durable FDA approved plastic
    4. Cost per shape ranges from $3.50 - $5.00 on a basic standard size outline cookie cutter
    5. Normal turnaround time 7-10 days
    6. We do not do cookie cutters with impressions in the middle...only outline cookie cutters.
    7. We do not make just one cookie cutter. Minimums are firm.

    Tin Cookie Cutter

    1. One time tooling fee. Price ranges from $400 - $800 for a standard 3" - 4" size. Tooling fees increase on larger shapes.
    2. Minimum quantity 500 pieces per design
    3. Made from tin plate steel manufactured here in the USA
    4. Contact us for pricing information
    5. Normal turnaround time 3-4 weeks
    6. We do not do cookie cutters with impressions in the middle...only outline cookie cutters.
    7. We do not make just one cookie cutter. Minimums are firm.

    Let us quote your custom cookie cutter project. Call Toll Free (866)756-6543 or email info@cookiecutter.com

  • What's the difference between plastic and metal cookie cutters?

    Metal cookie cutters are durable and easily cut through dough, while plastic cookie cutters are affordable and a good choice for anyone who doesn't want to handle a sharp cookie cutter. Plastic cutters are also great for kids to cut holiday shapes out of cookie dough, playdough, and clay.

  • What type of cookie cutters are least likely to rust?

    Stainless steel and copper cookie cutters are mostly rust resistant, but can rust if exposed to corrosive cleaners, high humidity and/or high salinity products such as sea salt. It's also suggested to wash and dry metal cookie cutters immediately after using them to prevent rust.

  • How do I choose a cookie cutter?

    When looking for cookie cutters, start by considering what occasions you plan on using them. There are cookie cutters for Christmas, Halloween, birthdays, and other holidays and events. Next, choose cookie cutters made with the material you need, such as metal or plastic. Each has its own benefits, so research what is best for you. Finally, consider if you will need a container to store your cookie cutters to hold them in between uses.

  • What's the difference between a cookie mold and a cookie cutter?

    Cookie molds are used to make cookies with more intricate designs, while cookie cutters usually cut dough into different shapes.

  • What are the different types of cookie cutters?

    The main types of cookie cutters are made from tin plated steel, plastic, stainless steel, aluminum, copper, and wood. Many of these are also available in different holiday and special occasion themes.


Other Cookie Cutter  Uses

Egg ring

For Eggs 

Use cookie cutters in various shapes to make eggs that are irresistible.  We have cookie cutters with handles that makes it easy to use them over a hot frying pan. They make the cutest egg.

christmas cookie cutters

As Christmas ornaments.

Just cut out and bake your favorite cookie in festive Christmas shapes and make a small hole in the top of the cookie. Let it dry and then add some ribbon to make the cookie into an ornament for your Christmas tree.


soap shapes made from cookie cutters

As Candle Forms


If you like to make tea candles, use cookie cutters as a form. Cover a sheet pan with parchment paper and add a small candlewick in the center. Heat your wax and let it cool slightly and then pour the wax while pressing down on the cookie cutter.


heart shaped bird feed

For the Birds


The winter months are hard for birds to find anything to eat. Use cookie cutters to make forms for pressed bird seed and gelatin, and then add a ribbon and hang the “ornaments” outside for the birds. See how to make these on Thrifty Jinxy.

baby shower cookie shapes

Baby Shower Reveal Cookies


Layer some cookies that you have cut into the shape of a onesie with a cookie cutter and add small candies to the center in both pink and blue. Make the sweetest ever shower centerpiece. See the project on Craft Storming.

using star cookie cutters to cut out pastry stars

Pastry Stars for slumber party.

Use cookie cutters to make pastry stars and then add them to taco cups that you have cooked in a muffin tin. They make a great mood setter for a slumber party. 
See how to do them here.

sports themed cookie cutters

For a Party Platter.


Use several different cookie cutters to cut both deli meats and cheeses into shapes. Then layer each shape on a platter.


This would be a super idea for any themed party or even just cut them into football shapes for the upcoming Super bowl!


pie toppers using mini cookie cutters

To Decorate Pie Crusts.

Make your pie and then roll out a circle of pie crust dough. Use small cookie cutters to cut out interesting shapes and lay them on top of the pie and bake. Martha Stewart would love this idea!




cookie cutters as decorations

For Kitchen Decorations.


Another Gardening Cook fan Retia Shealy suggested using cookie cutters as a kitchen decoration. She says “Mine are hung on my kitchen wall above my windows! I enjoy them year around!!” Great idea Retia!

cutting out watermelon pieces with star cookie cutter

As Melon Cutters. 


Don’t just make melon balls. Cut your watermelons or cantaloupes into slices first and then use cookie cutters to make interesting shapes and arrange for a party.

using a cookie cutter as a template on cake

For Cake Decorations.


Frost your cake first and then place a cookie cutter on the top and sprinkle cake sprinkles inside the cookie cutter. Remove the cookie cutter for a delightful cake decoration.




car freshie using a cookie cutter

As Car Air Fresheners.


Making your own air fresheners allows to you enjoy quality fragrances in your home, office or car without spending a lot. Making cookie-cutter air fresheners is a fun craft for even children and make wonderful gifts or craft bazaar sellers. To learn more, check out this how to from eHow!




using cookie cutters to make soap

As Soap Molds.

Do you like to make soap? Don’t pay for fancy molds. Use cookie cutters in your favorite shapes to hold your favorite DIY soap.





cookie cutter shaped rice krispie treats

For Huge Valentine Conversation Hearts.


Make Rice Krispie treats and then dip in colored candy melts and write sweet messages on them for Valentine’s Day.   Get the tutorial for these conversation hearts from Snappy Gourmet


cookie cutters cutting out shape in bread

As Sandwich Shapes. 


One of the fans of The Gardening Cook on Facebook, Deverea Northcutt suggested this idea. She said “I have five sons. When they were little, I would cut different sandwiches for their lunch with cookie cutters.


Deverea said that she always decorated the bag and had napkins to go with the shape theme. Lots of fun and memories.” What a great idea (and what a great mom!)


cookie cutters as package tie ons

For Package Decorations.


The kids will love this one. Use plain paper to wrap presents and then dip cookie cutters into paint and press on the paper and let it dry. Can be used for any holiday and so much cheaper than store bought paper.


cookie cutters used to cut out shapes in pumpkin carving

For Pumpkin Carving. 


Don’t carve your pumpkin with a knife. Use small cookie cutters and a rubber mallet to press the cutters into the pumpkin to make interesting shapes for your pumpkin face.

cookie cutters cutting out jello shapes

For Jello Jigglers.


Jello is the perfect medium for cookie cutters. It forms a fairly solid shape when done. But don’t just cut it into squares.



Use cookie cutters as molds to hold the jello until it forms. So much more fun for the kiddos! Check out our Jello Jiggler recipe!



Cookie Cutter wreath

For Wreath Decorations.


Transform any ordinary ever green wreath into a festive front door decoration by adding colorful plastic cookie cutters in Christmas shapes and matching ribbon.

Shaped pancakes with cookie cutters

Fun Shaped Pancakes.


Pancakes don’t have to be boring round shapes. Use medium and large sized cookie cutters as holders for your pancake batter. Let the batter cook on one side and then remove the cutter and flip it to brown on the other. Such fun!


Cookie cutter jewelry

Make a Necklace


DIY your own cookie cutter charm necklaces as cookie exchange party favors. It is an easy jewelry project to make. Find this fun DIY project here.

Fudge in a cookie cutter

Fun Shaped Fudge.


Make your fudge as you normally do but instead of cutting it into squares, just small cookie cutters for a really festive platter of fudge.

Cookie cutter dog treats

To Make Fun Dog treats


Cookies are not just for people, you know. Use cookie cutters to make doggy treats. Your pooch will thank you. He won’t care about the shape, of course, but you will have fun feeding them to him!  See how to make dog cookies.

heart cookie cutter french toast

Fun French Toast


Use large sized cookie cutters to cut your bread into fun shapes, then make your French toast as you normally do. Makes for a fun breakfast.

Cookie cutter stencil

Use as Powdered Sugar Stencils.


Don’t feel like frosting a whole cake (or don’t want the calories?) Just make a cake and then dip cookie cutters into powdered sugar and press lightly on the cake top for a low calorie decorative touch.

Cookie cutter Christmas ornament

For Baked Christmas Ornaments.


Use cookie cutters in Christmas shapes as forms, then add plastic beads and bake. The beads will melt and make lovely ornaments. Get our full Cinnamon Ornament recipe here!

Ghost shaped cookie cutters

For Pizza Toppings.


Use mini cookie cutters to cut your favorite toppings into fun shapes before decorating your pizza.

Christmas cookie cutter shaped pita bread

For Tortilla Chips.


Instead of just cutting pita bread into triangles, use cookie cutters to cut it into fun shapes before you bake them. So much more fun to eat!

Cookie cutter templates for scrapbooking

For Scrap Booking.


Retail prices on preformed scrapbook shapes can be quite costly. Use your cookie cutter to trace shapes onto scrapbook paper, and cut them out at a fraction of the cost.

S'mores shaped cookie cutters

For Cookie Cutter S’mores.


Add a fun twist on your s'mores by cut out shapes on the graham crackers! Check out the how to Here!

Cookie cutter gifts

For a Cookie Swap Invitation.


Tie an invitation to a cookie cutter to give to your guests to invite them to your annual cookie swap. They might even use the cookie cutter for their cookies. Make each invite different to have lots of fun shapes at the party.

Using cookie cutters with playdough

For Play Doh Fun.


Your kids will have hours of fun using cookie cutters to make shapes with their play dough

Using cookie cutters to cut out brownie shapes

For Brownies.


Good bye boring rectangular shaped brownies, and hello fun brownies. Line your pan with foil including over the side. Grease bottom and sides. Pour brownie mix in and bake. When completely cool, lift brownies out of pan, separate from foil. Cut brownies out using your favorite cookie cutter.

Cookie cutter napkin rings

As Napkin Rings.


Roll our napkins and push them through cookie cutters for an inexpensive napkin ring.


Share by: